Thursday, 03 October 2019 13:28

Building Good Search Skills: What Students Need to Know

Author:  [Source: This article was published in kqed.org By Tasha Bergson-Michelson]

The Internet has made researching subjects deceptively effortless for students -- or so it may seem to them at first. Truth is, students who haven't been taught the skills to conduct good research will invariably come up short.

That's part of the argument made by Wheaton College Professor Alan Jacobs in The Atlantic, who says the ease of search and user interface of fee-based databases have failed to keep up with those of free search engines. In combination with the well-documented gaps in students’ search skills, he suggests that this creates a perfect storm for the abandonment of scholarly databases in favor of search engines. He concludes: “Maybe our greater emphasis shouldn’t be on training users to work with bad search tools, but to improve the search tools.”

His article is responding to a larger, ongoing conversation about whether the ubiquity of Web search is good or bad for serious research. The false dichotomy short-circuits the real question: “What do students really need to know about an online search to do it well?” As long as we’re not talking about this question, we’re essentially ignoring the subtleties of Web search rather than teaching students how to do it expertly. So it’s not surprising that they don’t know how to come up with quality results. Regardless of the vehicle--fee databases or free search engines--we owe it to our students to teach them to search well.

So what are the hallmarks of a good online search education?

SKILL-BUILDING CURRICULUM. Search competency is a form of literacy, like learning a language or subject. Like any literacy, it requires having discrete skills as well as accumulating experience in how and when to use them. But this kind of intuition can't be taught in a day or even in a unit – it has to be built up through exercise and with the guidance of instructors while students take on research challenges. For example, during one search session, teachers can ask students to reflect on why they chose to click on one link over another. Another time, when using the Web together as a class, teachers can demonstrate how to look for a definition of an unfamiliar word. Thinking aloud when you search helps, as well.

A THOROUGH, MULTI-STEP APPROACH. Research is not a one-step process. It has distinct phases, each with its own requirements. The first stage is inquiry, the free exploration of a broad topic to discover an interesting avenue for further research, based on the student's curiosity. Web search, with its rich cross-linking and the simplicity of renewing a search with a single click, is ideally suited to this first open-ended stage. When students move on to a literature review, they seek the key points of authority on their topic, and pursue and identify the range of theories and perspectives on their subject. Bibliographies, blog posts, and various traditional and new sources help here. Finally, with evidence-gathering, students look for both primary- and secondary-source materials that build the evidence for new conclusions. The Web actually makes access to many --

but not all -- types of primary sources substantially easier than it's been in the past, and knowing which are available online and which must be sought in other collections is critical to students’ success. For example, a high school student studying Mohandas Gandhi may do background reading in Wikipedia and discover that Gandhi's worldview was influenced by Leo Tolstoy; use scholarly secondary sources to identify key analyses of their acquaintance, and then delve into online or print books to read their actual correspondence to draw an independent conclusion. At each step of the way, what the Web has to offer changes subtly.

TOOLS FOR UNDERSTANDING SOURCES. Some educators take on this difficult topic, but it's often framed as a simple black-and-white approach: “These types of sources are good. These types of sources are bad.” Such lessons often reject newer formats, such as blogs and wikis, and privilege older formats, such as books and newspaper articles. In truth, there are good and bad specimens of each, and each has its appropriate uses. What students need to be competent at is identifying the kind of source they're finding, decoding what types of evidence it can appropriately provide, and making an educated choice about whether it matches their task.

DEVELOPING THE SKILLS TO PREDICT, ASSESS, PROBLEM-SOLVE, AND ITERATE. It's important for students to ask themselves early on in their search, “When I type in these words, what do I expect to see in my results?” and then evaluate whether the results that appear match those expectations. Identifying problems or patterns in results is one of the most important skills educators can help students develop, along with evaluating credibility. When students understand that doing research requires more than a single search and a single result, they learn to leverage the information they find to construct tighter or deeper searches. Say a student learns that workers coming from other countries may send some of their earnings back to family members. An empowered searcher may look for information on [immigrants send money home], and notice that the term remittances appears in many results. An unskilled searcher would skip over words he doesn't recognize know, but the educated student can confirm the definition of remittance, then do another search, [remittances immigrants], which brings back more scholarly results.

TECHNICAL SKILLS FOR ADVANCED SEARCH. Knowing what tools and filters are available and how they work allows students to find what they seek, such as searching by colordomainfiletype, or date. Innovations in technology also provide opportunities to visualize data in new ways. But most fundamentally, good researchers remember that it takes a variety of sources to carry out scholarly research. They have the technical skills to access Web pages, but also books, journal articles, and people as they move through their research process.

Centuries ago, the teacher Socrates famously argued against the idea that the written word could be used to transmit knowledge. This has been disproved over the years, as authors have developed conventions for communicating through the written word and educators have effectively taught students to extract that knowledge and make it their own. To prepare our students for the future, it's time for another such transition in the way we educate. When we don’t teach students how to manage their online research effectively, we create a self-perpetuating cycle of poor-quality results. To break that cycle, educators can engage students in an ongoing conversation about how to carry out excellent research online. In the long term, students with stronger critical thinking skills will be more effective at school, and in their lives.

[Source: This article was published in kqed.org By Tasha Bergson-Michelson - Uploaded by the Association Member: Patrick Moore]

2 comments

  • Comment Link Shawnee Thursday, 10 October 2019 20:27 posted by Shawnee

    Whatt have you been reading nott too lengthy ago?
    Have you read anything good or anything at all?
    Have you noticed hhow thhe so-called 'major players' additional famous off individuals are always reading such and such hence they hav been thinking about such and
    such? Why do that these people quickly become center of atttention at
    any event or party? When was the last time you read a book/e-book?
    Are that you a 'wide reader'? A person even know you wrote a 'wide reader' is usually?



    First-time visitors who leave your site with a good opinion individual and
    the intentkon to send back later will forget where they found you
    instead come lower back. So you loose the sle that was prkbably only
    a few email messages away.

    3)Learn to read with focus and strength. Think of what you aare
    going through. Do not let your attention wander somewhere better.

    Good readers read with understanding. Good reader will
    have an idea where the writer may be leading the group.
    Mental chaallenges blossom and bloom as a bet onn 'out-smart-the characters' and person.

    Likewise, reading develops inttellectual curiosity by exposing one to a regarding materials.
    You learn too see by reading books of skyrocketing difficulty and variety.

    Likee for example other kinds of activity, you learn by actually making time for.

    Reading treains of which yoou have the world's and open mind.
    Merely grasping the writer's idea is inadequate.
    You must make good direction response as you just read.

    Be an active, not a passive, viewer. Develop the pracctice of drawing ones own conclusions, the habit oof active thinking, of agreeing or disagreeing the
    actual use of author. Maintain your mind open; understand and wekgh the
    minds thbat yyou read. A practicaal part of active reading
    iis enter of conclusions aas well as understanding another's reason for
    view, even though youu totally disagreed with himm or her.


    In this principle, try and recognize your fears, acknowledge them and then move through them.
    Consider what one thing maes you uncomfortable?
    An individual let yourself get in poor condktion andd are
    frightened you'll never get back? Do you have an injury that's caused you
    being afraid of your body?

    You won't like it if someone disrespected you.
    This logic applies tto people you medet as well. Showing respect
    too youyr friend is really important as per the relationship acvice online.
    You might be a male or a female, your girl needs to get a proper
    degree of resspect from you, just in case you wish
    become worse an feelings. Many individuals find it disrespectful after getting interrupted while talking or are pestered
    with unnecessary peronal concerns. Thus, you need to
    be soft spoken and polite with each of your partner.

    Life involves risk,and risk suggests the chances of failure.
    Be inmclined to take risks! You will find there'srisks
    lie what you'd like to learn and your rewards.

    Without thos marketing funnel in place, you undoubtedly missing out -- potentially even driving away -- those who could really
    benefit from what you have to offer and are a factor iin your bottom line, also.
    And that's how nott developing a marketing funnel hurts
    your pracice without you even knowing them.

  • Comment Link Magnolia Sunday, 06 October 2019 12:58 posted by Magnolia

    Learning the best way to up start an Internet business does never to be hard or overwhelming.

    There are all kinds of free software that you can use to get started.
    Keep your newsletters interesting so they will be
    read.

Leave a comment

airs logo

Association of Internet Research Specialists is the world's leading community for the Internet Research Specialist and provide a Unified Platform that delivers, Education, Training and Certification for Online Research.

Get Exclusive Research Tips in Your Inbox

Receive Great tips via email, enter your email to Subscribe.

Follow Us on Social Media

Book Your Seat for Webinar GET FREE REGISTRATION FOR MEMBERS ONLY      Register Now